Near the end of Rachel Kushner’s Creation Lake (2024), a peripheral character offers a summary of the novel’s plot so far:
“But thanks for this, sister.” Burdmoore patted the jacket pocket where he’d put the gun.
“I’ll keep it as a souvenir. It’ll remind me of that time some crazy chick came to Le Moulin and tried to stir up a bunch of shit and no one went for it.” (p. 388)
Le Moulin is a collective of eco-activists based in a “rural, southwestern department” (p. 7) of France. Members of Le Moulin have damaged earth-moving equipment in order to obstruct the building of an enormous underground reservoir (a “megabasin”). The book’s narrator, a 34-year-old American woman who is definitely not named “Sadie Smith”, though that and an earlier alias, “Amy”, are the only names for her that the reader knows, has been contracted to infiltrate the activists. Her job is to find out whether the Moulinards are planning any further sabotage (and, it’s implied, to incite them to do so if they’re not), so that they can be suppressed by the police. “Sadie” doesn’t know exactly who she’s working for, and doesn’t try to find out. It’s a reasonable inference that they are people who have an interest in seeing that the megabasin is built.
Le Moulin has a changing relationship with its former mentor, an old revolutionary and soixante-huitard named Bruno Lacombe, who used to be an associate of the (real-life) leftist, Guy Debord. Bruno, whom the narrator never gets to meet, now has very different ideas than he used to have when he knew Debord. He is opposed to civilization and no longer thinks that the proletariat can be counted on to dismantle the governing order or system.
Bruno has owned land near Le Moulin’s base for decades. After the death of his 8-year-old daughter in an accident with a tractor, his wife and older daughter moved away, and Bruno moved out of his farmhouse into one of a number of tiny, stone buildings on the land (apparent survivals from a much earlier era). Later still, he moved into a cave and discovered an extensive underground network, where he has now lived for years. He has been regularaly sending Le Moulin discursive emails in which he sets out his thinking, though their practice has diverged from his theories. To write and send these emails, he emerges from his subterranean domain and uses the computer in the farmhouse which is now occupied by his surviving daughter, Naïs. She runs (apparently on her own) the Café de la Route in the nearby village, which also has a church, a square and nothing much else.
“Sadie” has hacked into Bruno’s email account, guessing his password on her eleventh attempt, and having discovered his email address, which receives email only from Le Moulin, via a Google Alert (p. 44). The emails don’t reveal any plans for or incitement to further sabotage, but she is increasingly captivated by his outré pronouncements of varying degrees of implausibility. It becomes clear that Bruno is trying out a variety of ideas just as they occur to him about such big questions as what is to be done about the persistence of civilization, exploitation, hardship and other regrettable aspects of life on earth.
The earlier emails that “Sadie” reads praise the Neanderthals (whom Bruno sometimes calls “Thals”) at the expense of his own species, homo sapiens. The Neanderthals, he says, were good at maths, had bigger brains (because bigger skulls) as well as overdeveloped jaws. His statement that they had “enormous faces” (p. 4) has “Sadie” picturing them as looking like Joan Crawford. They enjoyed smoking tobacco. Bruno maintained that Neadeanderthals were the original artists, able “to bring into being something new” whereas homo sapiens was merely “a copier” (p. 83), skilled at depicting what was already there. It was remarkable, he thought, that evidence of Neanderthal ancestry was still to be found in the human genome.
And yet many people carry Neanderthal traces, he said. Two percent, four percent, this measure of ancient life was stunning, given that there have been no living communities of full Neanderthals actively contributing to the gene pool for forty thousand years. It’s as if our chromosomes cling to this old share, he said, as if it were a precious keepsake, an heirloom, the remnant of a person deep inside us who knew our world before the fall, before the collapse of humanity into a cruel society of classes and domination. (p. 9)
In response to questions from the Moulinards, Bruno revises his hypothesis somewhat, accepting that it’s possible that representatives of some earlier species of humanity (possibly including Neanderthals) may have survived, “living undetected on the margins of the modern world” (p. 33). They certainly continue to exist in our minds and in our culture. He implies that one such population might have been the Cagot. In 1594 these people were joined by the peasantry in a rebellion against the feudal lords, though in normal times the peasants, like everybody else, ostracized them and treated them as untouchable. Bruno tells his disciples that the Cagot rebellion took place in the vicinity of where Le Moulin is now based.
… there was an ancient rumor that the Cagot was a strain of earlier human, perhaps Neanderthal, which might account for why they had been barred from blending into the population. (p. 124)
He further suggests that Cagot heritage could have survived in hiding through the centuries since the rebellion, “a secret flame that is cupped and held and protected from the wind” (p. 129).
Spending more of his time underground, Bruno experiments with remaining in complete darkness. He tells the Moulinards that being surrounded by utter blackness stimulates his mental activity. On his first night in the dark, he sees the image of a photograph that he has previously seen, of Helen Keller.
In the darkest region of his cave, in absolute blindness, Bruno had pictured a blind person apprehending b beauty by smell and by touch.
To Bruno, the meaning of this paradox was self-evident: to not be physically blind, as he was not, was to be blind to what it meant not to see. (p. 227)
Towards the end of the story Bruno has come to modify his low opinion of homo sapiens. An article that he has read suggests to him that cave paintings, like those at Lascaux, might be something other than an attempt at realistic representation of the animals the humans hunted:
These depicted beasts on cave walls, long regarded as deities of the hunt, might instead have been deities of the sky. Not the animals that man hoped to trap and kill and skin and eat, but those animals that shone as arrangements of stars in the celestial heavens, wondrously out of reach. (p. 361)
They might be star maps. (And star maps are maps that facilitate navigation on earth, too.) Bruno includes in his email instructions on how to find Polaris, the North Star, by projecting a line through the last two stars of “the Big Dipper” (p. 362), also called “the Plough”. “Sadie” promptly goes outside and follows these instructions.
Our standard story, Bruno said, is that seafaring would not have been possible without the North Star you’ve just gone out to locate and behold, to ponder a little. (p. 363)
This “standard story” turned out to be wrong, because Polynesians were able to navigate vast areas of the South Pacific without being able to see the North Star. Bruno disputes the theory that the Polynesians navigated purely by reference to the stars, though of course the stars played an indispensable part.
But, Bruno said, they used more than mere stars. They used all of their senses. The smell and taste of the sea. The shapes and position of clouds. The direction of waves as they broke over the prow of the boat. If Polynesian sailors could not see the waves approaching their canoe, on account of fog or nighttime darkness, they stood up in their boat, their legs apart, so as to interpret swell patterns, Bruno said, by the sway of their own testicles. (p. 366)
This is fanciful, of course. Bruno has no special insight into how the Polynesian sailors fixed their courses. (And, as I understand it, it would be eminently possible, though more difficult, to steer by the stars without the help of the North Star.) His preoccupation with stars and other methods of wayfinding suggest that, following the failure of his revolutionary hopes in the 1960s, he was flailing about, searching for a new direction. His former comrades had their own ways of getting lost. Debord became depressed, drank too much and in 1994 killed himself with a gunshot to the heart.
A rift has opened between Bruno and another old comrade (fictional this time) named Jean Violaine, who also lives near Le Moulin and is in contact with the activists. Like Bruno, Jean has lost faith in the proletariat but he has instead transferred his hopes to the peasantry (who of course are declining in numbers). Like Debord, Jean has partly withdrawn into drink.
The appeal that Bruno’s notions hold for “Sadie” lies in the fact that she too is flailing about, though presumably not because of the failure of revolutionary ideals. She has seduced a filmmaker named Lucien Dubois, who believes she is going to marry him, as a way of approaching Le Moulin. (Lucien is the childhoold friend of Pascal Balmy, Le Moulin’s main theoretician and writer, and has inherited a family house nearby, which “Sadie” can use as a base while Lucien is making a film in Marseille.) Lucien is conceerned about her future.
He believed I was a former grad student who had lost her way. (I was a former grad student but I had found my way instead of losing it.) (p. 16)
In this respect at least, Lucien may see “Sadie” more clearly than she sees herself. As I’ve mentioned, she doesn’t know quite who is employing her, which suggests that her activities are motivated mainly by money, and that she doesn’t care who she is working for. When her contacts say they want the hapless Deputy Minister of Rural Coherence, Paul Platon, “neutralized” she at first answers “I am not a hitman” (p. 345), then sets what she expects will be a prohibitive additional fee, which they agree to pay. And when she warns them that Platon’s own intelligence may warn him to expect a big demonstration, so that he may cancel his appearance, they respond “We are his intelligence” (p. 328). One has the sense that Platon’s neutralization is required not because he’s a danger to anybody or as punishment for any past action on his part, but merely because he can easily be done without. If somebody must be sacrificed as an excuse for a clampdown on the demonstrators, Platon will fit the bill neatly.
The fee, when it comes, is enough to allow her to buy a E-Class Mercedes, which is also said to be the car of choice for workers on the Daimler assembly line who deliberately injure themselves to get compensation (pp. 279–80). Is there a suggestion here that “Sadie” has damaged or disabled herself through the work she has chosen to do?
The end of the novel is ambiguous. In contrast to Bruno, who goes deep underground in order to be guided by the stars, “Sadie” finds herself where she can view the night sky without obstruction. She’s in a coastal village in Spain: a tourist resort in summer, a fishing village in winter. And, for the moment, she’s there between the two, in October, in an in-between state. Is she better placed to find her way than Bruno is? Certainly, we can say that she isn’t where she claims to be. She has been responding to increasingly rare enquiries about work, saying that she has “retired to Priest Valley” (p. 404), a location that barely exists, nothing more than a road sign on a California highway.
I tried to write about Creation Lake back in August, but I didn’t manage to say what I wanted to, and didn’t post what I had written. I’m happier with the present post, though there are still some unfortunate gaps in it.
I’ve noticed that my reading has been slowing down in recent months, mainly because my eyesight has been disimproving. I’ve been on a waiting list for cataract surgery for just over a year. I’m delighted to say that I’ve now been given an appointment for the surgery to be carried out on one of my eyes. It’s on 4 December, just under three weeks away. In the normal course I’d be sending out newsletter posts the weeks before and after my appointment, i.e. 28 November and 12 December. I don’t know what effect the surgery will have on my reading and writing, so please expect disruption. Thanks for reading.
Edition: Jonahan Cape trade paperback, 2024.